New England Legal Foundation
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission & History
    • Annual Reports
    • Board of Directors
    • State Advisory Councils >
      • Connecticut
      • Maine
      • Massachusetts
      • New Hampshire
      • Rhode Island
      • Vermont
    • Trustees
    • Members
    • Staff
    • Job & Internship Opportunities
  • News & Events
  • Docket
  • Briefs
  • Donate
  • Contact

Feeney v. Dell Computer Corp. 

10/7/2009

 
Seeking to Enforce Class-Action Waivers in Consumer Arbitration Contracts

The principal legal issue in this putative consumer class action was whether Massachusetts would enforce waivers of class action arbitration included in the service contracts that the plaintiffs had purchased, where the waivers were unquestionably enforceable under the law applicable to the contracts (in this case, Texas law). (The plaintiffs alleged that, in violation of c. 93A, they had been improperly charged Massachusetts sales tax on the purchase of those contracts.)  The arbitral panel that initially heard the matter enforced the class action waivers and found for Dell on the plaintiffs’ Chapter 93A claims.  The Superior Court affirmed the arbitrators’ decision; on appeal, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court granted direct appellate review.  

NELF, joined by co-amicus Associated Industries of Massachusetts, submitted an amicus brief in support of Dell, arguing that, under basic contract law principles, the waivers could only be declared invalid if enforcing them would offend a fundamental Massachusetts public policy.   NELF argued that the waivers did not offend a fundamental policy in Massachusetts especially where, as here, the contracts expressly preserved the consumers’ statutory right to recover reasonable attorneys’ fees.  NELF also argued that, whether or not the waivers should be enforced, the plaintiffs had failed to state a claim because their complaint had to do with the collection of sales tax, which is not covered by Chapter 93A.  

In a decision likely to have a wide impact with respect to consumer sales, the SJC disagreed with NELF on the waiver issue, holding that Massachusetts does have a fundamental public policy in favor of consumer class actions under Chapter 93A and, as a result, waivers of class arbitration in consumer cases are unenforceable in Massachusetts.  Nevertheless, despite invalidating the waivers, the SJC agreed with NELF that the plaintiffs had not stated a consumer protection claim.  Since plaintiffs complain of Dell’s collection of sales tax, the SJC, based on its precedent that “[w]here a party’s actions are motivated by a ‘legislative mandate, not business or personal reasons’ Chapter 93A does not apply,” remanded the case to the trial court for dismissal without prejudice, providing an opportunity to the plaintiffs to allege, if they could, that there was a “profit-seeking” motive behind Dell’s collection of the tax.  The Court noted that the record is currently devoid of any such allegation or fact.


Comments are closed.

    The Docket

    To obtain a copy of any of NELF's briefs, contact us at info@nelfonline.org.

    Categories

    All
    1st Circuit Court Of Appeals
    2nd Circuit Court Of Appeals
    3rd Circuit Court Of Appeals
    Business Litigation Session
    CT
    CT Superior Court
    CT Supreme Court
    Employer Employee Relationships
    February 2018
    February 2019
    Government Regulation/Administration Of Justice
    MA
    MA Appeals Court
    MA Division Of Administrative Law Appeals
    March 2015
    MA Superior Court
    MA Supreme Judicial Court
    MA US District Court
    ME
    ME Supreme Judicial Court
    NH
    NH Supreme Court
    Property Rights
    RI
    RI Supreme Court
    SCOTUS
    United States Supreme Court
    US Court Of Appeals Federal Circuit
    US District Court ME
    VT
    VT Supreme Court

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    August 2020
    June 2020
    January 2020
    June 2019
    April 2019
    October 2018
    June 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    October 2016
    June 2016
    February 2016
    October 2015
    June 2015
    March 2015
    October 2014
    June 2014
    February 2014
    October 2013
    June 2013
    February 2013
    October 2012
    June 2012
    February 2012
    October 2011
    June 2011
    February 2011
    October 2010
    June 2010
    February 2010
    October 2009
    February 2009
    October 2008
    June 2008
    February 2008
    October 2007
    June 2007
    October 2006
    June 2006
    February 2006
    October 2005
    June 2005
    February 2005
    October 2004
    June 2004
    February 2004
    October 2003
    May 2003
    February 2003
    September 2002
    May 2002
    February 2002
    May 2001