New England Legal Foundation
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission & History
    • Annual Reports
    • Board of Directors
    • State Advisory Councils >
      • Connecticut
      • Maine
      • Massachusetts
      • New Hampshire
      • Rhode Island
      • Vermont
    • Trustees
    • Members
    • Staff
    • Job & Internship Opportunities
  • News & Events
  • Docket
  • Briefs
  • Donate
  • Contact

St. George Greek Orthodox Cathedral of Western Massachusetts, Inc. v. Springfield Fire Department and the City of Springfield

6/6/2012

 
Opposing a Municipality’s Attempt to Impose Local Restrictions on the State Building Code in Violation of the Home Rule Amendment

This case dealt with the interplay between state and local building regulations and the harmful effects that excessive regulation may have on private property rights. The Massachusetts state building code identifies four kinds of systems as the only ones that may be used to notify a fire department of a fire in a building. The City of Springfield, Massachusetts, issued an ordinance restricting use within the City to only one of these systems. In addition, the ordinance required removal and replacement of any of the other three systems whose use is permitted by the state building code. The St. George Greek Orthodox Cathedral of Western Massachusetts challenged Springfield’s ordinance in Superior Court and won. On appeal, the matter was taken by the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court (“SJC”), and NELF (joined by co-amicus NAIOP) filed an amicus brief in support of the Cathedral, arguing that the SJC should affirm because Springfield’s attempt to narrow the permissible range of systems thwarted the Massachusetts legislature’s intent to establish a comprehensive building code that is uniformly applicable across the Commonwealth. NELF also explained the ways in which the local restriction would conflict with other legislative goals, such as controlling costs and preventing unwarranted preferential treatment of devices and materials. NELF argued that, because the effect of the ordinance was to second-guess the discretionary decisions of the State Board of Building Regulation and Standards, the ordinance clearly was not local action authorized under the Massachusetts Home Rule Amendment, which grants certain rights to the Commonwealth’s cities and towns. In its decision issued on May 4, 2011, the SJC, agreeing entirely with NELF, ruled that Springfield had exceeded its authority when it enacted the ordinance limiting which of the fire notification systems could be used within the city. Following very closely NELF’s reasoning in its brief, the Court rejected the ordinance, holding that, “[w]here the Legislature demonstrates its express intention to preempt local action, inconsistent local regulations are invalid under the Home Rule Amendment.”

Comments are closed.

    The Docket

    To obtain a copy of any of NELF's briefs, contact us at info@nelfonline.org.

    Categories

    All
    1st Circuit Court Of Appeals
    2nd Circuit Court Of Appeals
    3rd Circuit Court Of Appeals
    Business Litigation Session
    CT
    CT Superior Court
    CT Supreme Court
    Employer Employee Relationships
    February 2018
    February 2019
    Government Regulation/Administration Of Justice
    MA
    MA Appeals Court
    MA Division Of Administrative Law Appeals
    March 2015
    MA Superior Court
    MA Supreme Judicial Court
    MA US District Court
    ME
    ME Supreme Judicial Court
    NH
    NH Supreme Court
    Property Rights
    RI
    RI Supreme Court
    SCOTUS
    United States Supreme Court
    US Court Of Appeals Federal Circuit
    US District Court ME
    VT
    VT Supreme Court

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    August 2020
    June 2020
    January 2020
    June 2019
    April 2019
    October 2018
    June 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    October 2016
    June 2016
    February 2016
    October 2015
    June 2015
    March 2015
    October 2014
    June 2014
    February 2014
    October 2013
    June 2013
    February 2013
    October 2012
    June 2012
    February 2012
    October 2011
    June 2011
    February 2011
    October 2010
    June 2010
    February 2010
    October 2009
    February 2009
    October 2008
    June 2008
    February 2008
    October 2007
    June 2007
    October 2006
    June 2006
    February 2006
    October 2005
    June 2005
    February 2005
    October 2004
    June 2004
    February 2004
    October 2003
    May 2003
    February 2003
    September 2002
    May 2002
    February 2002
    May 2001